Finessing Hippocrates
The original text of the Hippocratic oath applicable to medical practice, complete with pledging to Apollo to "do no harm", has been rightly overhauled for modern use. "No harm" sounds exactly right until you are a surgeon trying to introduce medical implements into the human body. Under those circumstances, a precisely calibrated amount of harm is a necessary part of the health intervention.
We find a similarly necessary calibration within the dose-response curve throughout biology. Take the human experience of water. Too little? Death. Too much? Death again. As Goldilocks sagely advised, somewhere in the middle is just about right. But while water is vital for life, even the effect of toxins and stressors can exhibit what is known as hormesis, a biphasic dose-response. Many such toxins are present within plants, and therefore our diet. The simple act of eating well is a daily demonstration that small exposures to poisonous substances can kickstart protective responses causally related to better biological outcomes.
A recent example of something very like hormesis is the novel use of carbon dioxide (CO2) in approaching neurodegenerative conditions that often arise as part of aging. Whilst lacking the straightforwardly deadly reputation of its less-oxygenated sibling, CO2 was labelled an "often forgotten" toxin in a medical context by researchers in 2017. It will always raise eyebrows, then, when CO2 presents as a potentially useful treatment for otherwise intractable conditions.
In 2025 a team from New Mexico and the Netherlands published on the use of intermittent hypercapnia (elevated CO2) in patients, including some with Parkinson's disease (PD). Just three ten-minute sessions triggered an increased clearance of proteins implicated in brain disease processes - notably amyloid and tau. Glymphatic clearance, where cerebrospinal fluid (CSF) flushes waste products from the brain, is known to be progressively weakened within Parkinson's disease. Anything that improves such clearance is therefore a potentially significant treatment.
In July 2026, New Scientist reported that researchers from the CO2 Parkinson's study presented results to the Alzheimer's Association International Conference (AAIC). Improved waste clearance is a general good for healthy aging of the brain, and the glymphatic process is known to decline with age, impacting memory even in those undiagnosed with any condition. Success within larger studies might, therefore, drive this idea into much wider use. We will first do some harm, but only to unlock a far greater good. Hippocrates would surely approve.
References:
Erhardt, Erik B et al. (2025) “The influence of intermittent hypercapnia on cerebrospinal fluid flow and clearance in Parkinson's disease and healthy older adults.” NPJ Parkinson's disease vol. 11,1 334. 21 Nov. 2025, doi:10.1038/s41531-025-01179-6
Rajai Firouzabadi, Shahryar et al. (2026) “Glymphatic Dysfunction in Parkinson's Disease: A Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis of Neuroimaging Studies.” Movement disorders clinical practice vol. 13,2 (2026): 331-343. doi:10.1002/mdc3.70296
Permentier, Kris et al. (2017) “Carbon dioxide poisoning: a literature review of an often forgotten cause of intoxication in the emergency department.” International journal of emergency medicine vol. 10,1 (2017): 14. doi:10.1186/s12245-017-0142-y
Wang, Yida, and Zhao Wang. (2025) “Dietary hormesis: beyond nutrition and energy supply.” NPJ science of food vol. 9,1 144. 21 Jul. 2025, doi:10.1038/s41538-025-00518-4
Voumvourakis, Konstantinos I et al. (2023) “The Dynamic Relationship between the Glymphatic System, Aging, Memory, and Sleep.” Biomedicines vol. 11,8 2092. 25 Jul. 2023, doi:10.3390/biomedicines11082092
Previous posts
When mathematicians were human
The book When Computers Were Human (Grier 2005) describes how a skilled craft was invented, evolved and grew and then was swept away by the first few generations of electronic computers. When the tide receded, what remained were the even more skilled mathematicians who programmed the computers.
Reading the (actuarial) runes
While researching my paper on the actuarial origins of survival models (Richards, 2026), I had cause to re-read Gompertz (1825). Strictly speaking I should say "re-try", as I failed in my first attempt to read his paper many years ago. Part of the reason for this was notation that was incomprehensible to me in the late 1980s. Figure 1 shows an example:
Figure 1. Expression from Gompertz (1825, p.539).
Add new comment